Cheesecake is a smooth, creamy dessert, which tastes delicious. If you thaw the leftover cake and end up having just a slice or two, you would still want the softness to remain intact.
So, to achieve the desired results might compel you to think, can you refreeze cheesecake?
You can safely keep the cheesecake refrozen for almost eight months. However, freezing it more than once can alter the quality overall. The refrozen cheesecake will not taste as great as a freshly baked one. But, you can safely eat it unless the 8-month limit has passed or you start noticing signs of spoilage.
Refreezing the cheesecake is a great way to extend its shelf-life. We have highlighted some proven tips and tricks below that help refreeze the cheesecake better.
Table of Contents
Is it Safe to Refreeze Cheesecake?
Cheesecake’s rich texture makes it irresistible and the top favorite of cheese enthusiasts. But, people tend to avoid refreezing cheese, as they have doubts regarding the negative health impact it may cause. The good news is that using it after refreezing won’t cause you any harm.
If you are still looking for a way to save the leftover cake, good for you that it is safe to refreeze cheesecake after refilling with the same ingredients. However, you should remember that refreezing is only allowed if thawed in a refrigerator.
Refreezing the cake after thawing it using other methods is not recommended as it significantly changes the texture. It would be best to avoid it because cake thawed on a countertop or at room temperature has a higher risk of contamination.
Please make sure that if you refreeze the cheesecake, you don’t let it sit at a temperature greater than 40 F for more than 2 hours. Bacteria and microbes multiply quickly at a temperature greater than 40 F, so it’s best to keep it refrigerated when you don’t want to refreeze it.
If you want the cheesecake to retain most of its flavor and texture, refreeze it immediately after removing it from the refrigerator. Another way to help it stay in a better condition is by refreezing it unfilled.
Filled cheesecake may become soft and soggy after refreezing. It makes it less appealing and enjoyable, but you can still eat it if you follow the refreezing instructions carefully.
The Best Way to Refreeze Cheesecake
If you are looking for a secure way to refreeze your cheesecake, you can do so by following some easy steps discussed below.
- First, let it slowly thaw overnight. A fully defrosted cake will refreeze better and save the cake from freezer burns.
- Take the thawed cake and start cutting it into slices.
- After that, carefully wrap the slices individually in aluminum foil or plastic sheet. Individually wrapping them will allow you to refreeze in portions. It will enable you to take out the required pieces quickly.
- Next, place the wrapped slices in an airtight freezer-safe container. Double wrapping them will reduce their exposure to open air.
- Label the container with the refreezing date to track how much longer it is safe to eat.
- Shift the labeled container to the coldest part of the freezer and place it on a leveled surface.
Note: Avoid piling up too many things on the top of the container as it will not let the cheesecake freeze properly.
How Long Can You Refreeze Cheesecake?
If you are careful enough, you can safely refreeze cheesecake for 6-8 months. Although the quality might be affected, it will still be safe to eat. However, once this limit crosses, you should toss it out immediately. Eating it after the six-month limit pass is no more edible.
If you want to ensure proper refreezing of cheesecake, make sure you refreeze it unfilled. As refreezing, it filled will make the crust mushy after thawing.
Storing it in an airtight container and double wrapping will help it preserve most of the taste and texture.
You should also avoid refilling the cake with different ingredients as it increases the chances of spoilage.
It is advised not to refreeze cheesecake more than once, as the cream might start crumbling. You can refreeze it in portions instead. Refreezing in separate batches will also make taking out just the required amount. Moreover, it will help you save the leftover cake from unnecessary thawing.
How Can You Tell the Refrozen Cheesecake has Gone Bad?
Refreezing the cheesecake is a safe practice, and it helps you increase its shelf-life significantly. However, no matter how well you refreeze it, it will lose freshness sooner or later. We have discussed some commonly observed signs of spoilage below to ensure you don’t eat the cake once it has spoiled.
- If the cake has molds on the surface, the cheesecake is no longer safe for use.
- If you notice any discoloration, it is also a sign that you should discard it.
- An unpleasant/sour smell also indicates that you should not eat the cake.
If you don’t notice any of these signs yet, the cake tastes off; you should no longer store it.
You can safely refreeze the cheesecake for an extended period. Freezing it in portions will make the process even simpler for you. Cheesecake packed in an airtight container will successfully store the most freshness and quality.
However, for the cheesecake to refreeze correctly, it is crucial to follow the refreezing instructions with care, or else you might end up spoiling it.
You can practice the steps mentioned above, containing all the required information about refreezing cheesecake.