Can You Refreeze Butter? (Here’s How)

Can You Refreeze Butter

Rich in flavors and nutrients, you may believe everything is better with butter. If you can’t risk being out of your butter stock at home, you might prefer buying your favorite brand in a bulk amount.

The versatile nature of butter can complement every dish, and you may use it frequently. But, once thawed, it might make you wonder if you can refreeze butter?

You can refreeze butter, and it is safe to do so. It should be defrosted in the fridge beforehand so it can undergo refreezing. Store your butter in sturdy packaging or container to ensure the quality remains unchanged. This step is applicable for both store-bought and homemade varieties. You can divide the butter into small portions if you intend to skip refreezing.

Dairy products like butter often require gentle handling due to their delicate nature. Refreezing it can become a little tricky and complicated. We are here today to make the refreezing journey a lot easier for you. Let’s start!

Refreezing Butter: Is It A Good Idea?

Butter can enhance the taste of almost anything and pairs nicely with multiple items. It makes it one of the most widely used taste builders and a kitchen must. Keeping this insight, it is apparent why increasing the shelf life of butter is crucial.

Once you thaw butter, you can be reluctant to toss it back in the freezer. The good news is that you can refreeze butter after defrosting. However, certain limitations are necessary, and you should keep track.

You can refreeze butter only if you thaw it in the refrigerator. Other defrosting techniques might not favor the refreezing process. It is due to the exposure of butter to air contamination and varying temperatures. As a result, it makes the butter unstable to withstand another round of freezing.

Similarly, butter type can also be a factor that determines if you can refreeze it or not. Salted butter generally lasts longer compared to its unsalted versions. The same is the case with homemade and factory-generated ones.

How To Refreeze Butter?

You can refreeze butter by following the steps listed below.

  • Refreeze the store-bought butter in the original packaging. It helps in identifying the product with ease. Also, it has the best by the date mentioned over it.
  • For additional safety, shift it in a heavy-duty freezer bag or container. It will give extra protection and prevent freezer burns.
  • If you have already removed the store wrapping, use aluminum foil or plastic wrapping.
  • In the case of homemade butter, divide it into meal-size portions and wrap them individually in wax paper. Afterward, put these wrapped batches inside a freezer bag.
  • This step will save you from refreezing it again in the future and defrosting only the required amount.
  • Don’t forget to label the bag with the date of refreezing, and it will serve as a reminder.

Note: avoid leaving your butter in the freezer for too long after refreezing it. The more it stays inside, the higher the risk of freezer burn.

How Long Can You Refreeze Butter?

The refreezing span of the butter can vary depending upon its type and how you thawed it initially. Factory-manufactured butter has a longer freezer life than its homemade counterpart. It is due to the addition of preservatives that allows it to remain in a good state after twice freezing.

Similarly, it is important to thaw the butter in the fridge if you plan to refreeze it. Leaving it on the countertop for longer durations and refreezing might not go hand in hand. If you prefer a fast thawing method like in the microwave, you should drop the idea of refreezing.

On average, you can keep the butter for about four months in the refrigerator and up to one year in the freezer. The homemade butter can last for less time and is fresh for a few months.

However, refreezing can potentially reduce the quality of the butter. Be ready to witness a considerable change in the taste and consistency of the butter once refrozen.

Can You Refreeze Different Butter Products?

Butter braids

Butter braids pastries are rich in flavors and contain mouthwatering fillings ranging from cream cheese to various fruit flavors. They can last in the freezer until you are finally ready to utilize them.

But, once you notice that the pastry has started the rising process, it is no longer a good option to refreeze the product. Though it is safe, the refreezing might affect the quality and flavors of your favorite pastry.


If you thaw buttermilk in the fridge, it can undergo refreezing without any trouble. It is crucial to maintain the temperature of the milk. If you defrost it at room temperature or in the microwave, it is vulnerable to bacterial growth. So, it is better to use the whole quantity right away or discard the leftovers.

Freezing the buttermilk in small portions in ice cube trays or bags can prevent the repeated thawing and freezing cycle. It is an easy alternative for keeping the quality of the milk intact.


Buttercream works as an excellent topping for cakes due to its sweet and delicious flavor. So, if you have some leftover quantity, you can successfully freeze it again.

The texture might suffer to some degree, but it is still edible and otherwise healthy to consume. If you do not mind a taste change, you can go ahead and refreeze your buttercream for future usage.

Butter tarts

Either homemade or store-bought, butter tarts can refreeze well if thawed in a refrigerator. However, ensure to store them in an airtight container or Tupperware before placing them inside the freezer.

The safety packaging will help in preventing freezer burns. Besides, it will also stop the butter tarts from getting soggy.

Butter icing

Just like buttercream, you can place the butter icing back in the freezer after thawing. You have to keep in mind that the harsh freezer environment can alter the overall consistency and creaminess of the frosting.

The icing might not look as rich as it was in the beginning, but it is good to make use of it rather than waste it. It possesses no health threats and can go as a topping.

Thawing Refrozen Butter: How To Do It Safely

The recommended way to thaw your frozen butter is by placing it in the fridge overnight. Usually, it takes around eight hours for a block of butter to defrost entirely. The refrigerator enables it to defrost gradually and results in even thawing. Also, refrigerator thawing allows you to freeze the remaining portion again without worrying about spoilage.

Microwaving the butter is a quicker option and melts it in some seconds. In this case, the butter reaches a high internal temperature ideal for bacteria to multiply rapidly. Thus, you must go with this method to utilize all the quantities of butter that you thaw.

Another conventional way of defrosting butter is by leaving it at room temperature. It takes up to three to four hours to defrost at room temperature. You can also grate the butter to speed up the thawing process.

Once you thaw refrozen butter, try to use it all as freezing it again can reduce the quality drastically. Go for the portion freezing method to avoid the unnecessary hassle of thawing and freezing.


Refreezing butter is safe and stops the outcome of food wastage. As high-quality butter is quite expensive, you might not want to throw it away. The repeated freezing can give the butter a slightly grainy texture. Still, it is perfectly okay to use it in different dishes of your choice.

Different kinds of butter react accordingly to the refreezing process. The freezing span can be more or less depending upon whether the butter was salted or unsalted, homemade or store-bought.

Undoubtedly, refreezing has some good aspects, but you need to perform it with the directed steps. Always opt for refrigerator thawing if you want to freeze the leftover butter again. Freezer-safe packaging can help to keep the butter fresh and flavorful for extended periods.

You can adapt the portion freezing technique to avoid refreezing. It not only makes the thawing experience much easier, but it also allows you to enjoy the optimum flavor of your butter.


Tauseeq is the principal creator of He loves cooking and wants to help others overcome kitchen challenges through practical advice and solutions.

Recent Posts