Can You Refreeze Uncrustables? Here’s Why You Shouldn’t

Can You Refreeze Uncrustables

The sweet combination of jelly and peanut butter is what makes the Uncrustables stand apart from other sandwiches. You might drool over them for the same reason and purchase their jumbo pack.

Once you thaw the Uncrustables to satisfy your hunger, you might be puzzled about what to do with the leftovers. No one wants to waste food that is still edible, so you may want to ask, can you refreeze Uncrustables?

You cannot refreeze store-bought Uncrustables, and it is not advisable to do so. Refreezing can initiate the formation of ice crystals, and the sandwiches will lose their texture and flavors. Technically, you may refreeze homemade Uncrustables if they thaw in the refrigerator. Ensure to wrap them properly and not let them sit in the open air for long.

Uncrustables are a treat for the kids, and you can keep them stored if you perform a few precautionary steps. Let’s discover the downside of refreezing them and what other safety measurements you must take.

Is It Safe To Refreeze Uncrustables?

Uncrustables are delicious sealed crustless sandwiches and are equally loved by every age group. The yummy peanut butter filling makes it almost irresistible. When it comes to storage, they remain frozen in the freezer for a decent amount of time, but you might be wondering if they can freeze again after thawing.

It is not ideal freezing the Uncrustables twice. Because, after one round of freezing and defrosting, the bread becomes soggy and is in a delicate state. Refreezing will further affect its texture due to the formation of ice crystals. As a result, they will lose many flavors and taste unpleasant.

The bread used in Uncrustables is soft, and the harsh freezer environment can alter its quality. It is better to utilize your sandwiches after the initial freezing and avoid placing them back in the freezer. Though they will still be safe to eat after refreezing, you may not enjoy them afterward, so it is not an ideal option.

Refreezing Homemade Uncrustables

If you prefer making your own homemade Uncrustables, you might want to preserve them for a longer duration. Let’s assume you thaw some amount for serving your family and left with some uneaten batch. You can successfully opt for refreezing. But, it can significantly reduce the quality of the sandwiches, and they may not taste as great as they did before.

However, if you do not mind a slight texture change, refreezing can work for you. It is crucial to thaw your Uncrustables in a refrigerator if you plan to freeze them again. Other defrosting methods, such as microwaving them or letting them sit on the countertop, might not facilitate the refreezing process.

Refreezing Store-Bought Uncrustables

When you purchase store-bought Uncrustables, they are already in a frozen form. There is a chance they might thaw while you are driving back home. In such a situation, you need to put the sandwiches back in the freezer as soon as possible. If you delay it and keep them in the open air for too long, they cannot freeze well as there is a high chance of contamination.

So, you should consume your Uncrustables if they sit on the counter for more than an hour. Similarly, if you place them in the freezer to thaw, they can last there for a maximum of twenty-four hours. After these limits exceed, your sandwich might be unsafe for consumption.

The sandwiches can spoil very quickly due to the processed peanut butter filling. Thus, refreezing might not save them from turning rancid, and ultimately you have to discard them.

The Easiest Method To Avoid Refreezing Uncrustables

Undoubtedly, Uncrustables is a convenient snack and a blast of rich flavors. But, it can be a hassle to store the unused amount as freezing them again is not a reliable option. No worry, you can instead opt for a much more handy storage method, portion freezing your sandwiches.

It will allow you to thaw only the amount you require, eliminating the tiresome work of thawing and freezing repeatedly. Also, your Uncrustables will remain fresh and intact as they have minimum contact with the air. Let’s find out the steps required for this technique.

  • For homemade Uncrustables, wrap individual sandwiches in high-quality plastic wrap or aluminum foil.
  • Secure all the edges well, allowing no room for air to enter inside. It will help prevent air contamination and bacterial growth.
  • To give another layer of safety, secure the sandwiches in Ziploc bags.
  • For store-bought Uncrustables with sealed packaging, you can keep them in a heavy-duty freezer bag.
  • If you removed them from the original packaging, you should store them in vacuum-sealed bags or containers.
  • Label the bag with the date of refreezing and take out the amount as per your requirement.

How To Thaw Frozen Uncrustables? The Right Technique

So, you bought a whole box of Uncrustables and placed them in the freezer. You might want to thaw them effectively to maintain their texture. There are many defrosting options that you can try depending upon your requirement.

The first method is defrosting your Uncrustables by letting them sit at room temperature for about thirty to sixty minutes. Avoid exceeding this time limit as the sandwiches may get infected with microbes. Once they fully thaw, eat them within six to eight hours to get the best flavors.

Another method is keeping the Uncrustables in the refrigerator. They can stay inside for up to twenty hours, and you should consume them within this time. If you leave them in the fridge for longer than one day, they might turn mushier and undergo a taste change.


Uncrustables cannot refreeze well as they are prone to suffer quality loss. Inside the freezer, the sandwiches will lose their original texture, but you want to avoid it happening. The homemade variant may refreeze for a while but at the cost of a decrease in the taste.

If you are not a fan of soggy sandwiches, you need to drop the idea of refreezing Uncrustables. Also, it is necessary to thaw them in the right way so that you can enjoy them and serve them to others as well. Microwaving them might be a faster option, but it is better to thaw them in a fridge or at room temperature.

Never leave them in the open air for an extended period, or they can spoil. If you expose the Uncrustables to the air for more than two hours on the countertop, you should toss them. Consuming the sandwiches afterward can cause stomach-related illnesses. Thus, it is ideal to utilize your Uncrustables soon after purchasing them and avoid storing them for longer.


Tauseeq is the principal creator of He loves cooking and wants to help others overcome kitchen challenges through practical advice and solutions.

Recent Posts